Thứ Hai, 13 tháng 9, 2021

Kỳ 4 : Kinh Kim Cang - ( với Từ Vựng Sanskrit )

                                  

                  KINH KIM CANG
                            THE DIAMOND SUTRA
                       (With Sanskrit Vocabulary)


                       P4: Công Đức  Vô Trụ Tướng Bố Thí

                                   -----------------

        वज्रच्छेदिका नाम त्रिशतिका प्रज्ञापारमिता ।
                 || नमो भगवत्या  आर्यप्रज्ञापारमितायै॥
                             -----------------------

                           Vajracchedikā
          nāma triśatikā prajñāpāramitā |

           || namo bhagavatyā āryaprajñāpāramitāyai ||
                           --------------------------
     I. Sanskrit - P4
     1/ Devanagari - S4

     (1). अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभुते न बोधिसत्त्वेन वस्तुप्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्, न क्वचित्प्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्|
    (2)- न रूपप्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्|
     (3)-शब्दगन्धरसस्प्रष्टव्यधर्मेषु प्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्|
    (4)- एवं हि सूभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन दानं दातव्यं यथा न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि प्रतितिष्ठेत्|
     (5)- तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो दानं ददाति, तस्य सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्य न सुकरं प्रमाणामुद्ग्रहीतुम्|
    (6)- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते सुकरं पूर्वस्यां दिशि आकाशस्य प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्|
    (7)- भगवानाह- एवं दक्षिणपश्चिमोत्तरासु अध ऊर्ध्वं दिग्विदिक्षु समन्ताद्दशसु दिक्षु सुकरमाकाशस्य प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्|
    (8)- भगवानाह-एवमेव सुभूते यो बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो दानं ददाति, तस्य सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्य न सुकरं प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम्|
    (9)- एवं हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन दानं दातव्यं यथा न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि प्रतितिष्ठेत्॥४॥

-------------------------
     2/ Romanized (IAST) and numbered - S4

     (1.1)- api tu khalu 1.2 punaḥ 1.3 subhute 1.4 na bodhisattvena 1.5 vastupratiṣṭhitena 1.6 dānaṁ dātavyam, 1.7 na kvacitpratiṣṭhitena 1.8 dānaṁ dātavyam |
    (2.1) na rūpapratiṣṭhitena 2.2 dānaṁ dātavyam |
    (3.1) na śabdagandharasaspraṣṭavyadharmeṣu 3.2 pratiṣṭhitena 3.3 dānaṁ dātavyam |
    (4.1) evaṁ 4.2 hi sūbhūte 4.3 bodhisattvena mahāsattvena 4.4 dānaṁ dātavyaṁ 4.5 yathā 4.6 na nimittasaṁjñāyāmapi 4.7 pratitiṣṭhet |
    (5,1) tatkasya hetoḥ ? 5.2 yaḥ subhūte 5.3 bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito 5.4 dānaṁ dadāti, 5.5 tasya subhūte 5.6 puṇyaskandhasya 5.7 na sukaraṁ 5.8 pramāṇāmudgrahītum |
    (6.1). tatkiṁ 6.2 manyase subhūte 6.3 sukaraṁ 6.4 pūrvasyāṁ 6.5 diśi 6.6 ākāśasya 6.7 pramāṇamudgrahītum ?
6.8 subhūtirāha-no 6.9 hīdaṁ 6.10 bhagavan |
     (7.1) bhagavānāha- evaṁ 7.2 dakṣiṇapaścimottarāsu 7.3 adha 7.4 ūrdhvaṁ 7.5 digvidikṣu 7.6 samantāddaśasu 7.7 dikṣu 7.8 sukaramākāśasya 7.9 pramāṇamudgrahītum ? 7.10 subhūtirāha-no 7.11 hīdaṁ bhagavan |
    (8.1) bhagavānāha-evameva 8.2 subhūte yo 8.3 bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito 8.4 dānaṁ dadāti, 8.5 tasya 8.6 subhūte 8.7 puṇyaskandhasya 8.8 na sukaraṁ 8.9 pramāṇamudgrahītum |
    (9.1) evaṁ hi subhūte 9.2 bodhisattvayānasaṁprasthitena 9.3 dānaṁ dātavyaṁ 9.4 yathā 9.5 na nimittasaṁjñāyāmapi 9.5 pratitiṣṭhet ||4||
-------------------
     3/ Vocabulary - S4

     - (1.1). अपि तु खलु api tu khalu
-api (indecl.)= too, also, even./ - tu (indecl.)= but, however. / - khalu (indecl.)= indeed, now further, truly.
- 1.2. पुनः punaḥ (adv.)= again, पुनर् punar= once again.
- 1.3.सुभुते subhute ( voc. sing.of subhuti) = (person name), Venerable Subhuti !
- 1.4. न बोधिसत्त्वेन na bodhisattvena
- na (adv.)= not, no
- bodhisattvena (n. enstr. sing. of bodhisattva)= by the enlightened being, by Bodhisattva.
- 1.5. वस्तुप्रतिष्ठितेन vastupratiṣṭhitena =
- vastu (n. acc. sing. of vastu)= the object, thing, item article,
- pratiṣṭhitena (adj. instr. sing. of pratiṣṭhita)= by dependent on, by situated on.
-1.6. दानं dānaṁ [ n. acc. sing. of dāna / m =>ṁ (10th CSR)] = donation, giving, gift
- दातव्यम् dātavyam (adj. )= to be placed upon, should be given.
-1.7. न क्वचित्प्रतिष्ठितेन na kvacitpratiṣṭhitena = by no means situated on
- na kvacit (indecl.)= by no means, not any place, not any where,
-pratiṣṭhitena = (see 1.5)
1.8. दानं दातव्यम् dānaṁ dātavyam = (see 1.6)
------------------
-(2.1). न रूपप्रतिष्ठितेन na rūpapratiṣṭhitena = not depended upon the form
- rūpa (n)= form, figure
- pratiṣṭhitena = (see 1.5)
-2.2. दानं दातव्यम् dānaṁ dātavyam
(see 1.6)
---------------
      -(3.1). न शब्दगन्धरसस्प्रष्टव्यधर्मेषु na śabdagandharasaspraṣṭavyadharmeṣu= neither sound, nor smell, nor taste, nor feeling, nor existence.
- śabda (m.)= noise, sound / - gandha (m.)=smell, scent / -rasa (m)= taste /-spraṣṭavya (n) =touch, feeling/
- dharmeṣu (m. loc. pl. of dharma)= law, method, phenomena, things, existence
-3.2. प्रतिष्ठितेन pratiṣṭhitena = (see 1.5)
- 3.3. दानं दातव्यम् dānaṁ dātavyam= (see 1.6)
------------------

     -(4.1). एवं evaṁ (indecl.)= thus. so, such., in this manner.
4.2. हि hi (indecl.)= for, because,
- सूभूते sūbhūte = (see 1.3)
4.3. बोधिसत्त्वेन bodhisattvena -(see 1.4)
- महासत्त्वेन mahāsattvena (m. instr.sing. of mahāsattva)= great enlightened being, great Bodhisattva.
4,4. दानं दातव्यं dānaṁ dātavyaṁ = (see 1.6)
4,5. यथा yathā (indecl.)= for instance, in such a manner as follows, namely , in such a way that,
-4,6. न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि na nimittasaṁjñāyāmapi = also no reason of the notion …
- na = not, no, without
- nimitta (n)= mark, omen, cause, reason, grond, motive
- saṁjñāyām <= sañjñāyām (f. loc. sing. of sañjñā / followed by Palatal cons. “j” m (of sam) =>ṁ => ñ (Nasal in Palatal class), see 10th - 11th CSR. ]= in notion, in conception
- api (indecl.)= too, also
-4,7.प्रतितिष्ठेत् pratitiṣṭhet (v. pratitiṣṭhati)= base on, depend or rely on.
------------------
     - (5,1). तत्कस्य हेतोः tatkasya hetoḥ ?= that is whose the sake?
- tatkasya (sent.)= whose that,
- hetoḥ ? =(m. gen. sing. of heto)= for. for the sake of
5.2. यः सुभूते yaḥ subhūte
- yaḥ (prn)= anyone who…
- subhūte = (see 1.3)
5.3. बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito=
- bodhisattvo <= bodhisattvaḥ [n. nom. sing. of bodhisattva. / preceding “a” (of pratiṣṭhito), aḥ => o, “a” => ‘ , aḥ + a = o’ ( by 2ndVSR) ]= enlightened being, one who has perfect wisdom and compassion.
-pratiṣṭhito <=apratiṣṭhitaḥ (adj. nom.sing.of apratiṣṭhita / followed by soft cons, “d” (of dānaṁ),aḥ=> o , (2ndVSR) ] = unlimited, independent, not relied on
-5.4. दानं dānaṁ [ n. acc. sing. of dāna / m =>ṁ ( by 10th CSR)] = donation, giving, gift 

- ददाति dadāti (v.)= give 

  - 5.5. तस्य सुभूते tasya subhūte= Subhūti ! His…
- tasya (poss. prn.) = his, / - subhūte= (see 1.3)
-5.6. पुण्यस्कन्धस्य puṇyaskandhasya=
the quantity of virtue (of)
- puṇya (n)= virtue, merit / - skandhasya (m. gen. sing. of skandha)= quantity (of),
- 5.7. न सुकरं na sukaraṁ = not easy for
- sukaraṁ (adj. acc. sing. of sukara)= easy to be managed, easy for, convenient,
- 5.8. प्रमाणामुद्ग्रहीतुम् pramāṇāmudgrahītum=
- pramāṇām (n.)= right measure.
- ( adj. udgrāhita) = recited
-------------------------
     -(6.1).तत्किं tatkiṁ (indecl)= what,
- 6.2. मन्यसे manyase (v. manyati)= think
- सुभूते subhūte = (see 1.3)
- 6.3. सुकरं sukaraṁ= easy for, (see 5.7)
-6.4. पूर्वस्यां pūrvasyāṁ <= pūrvāyāṁ(?) (f. loc. sing. of pūrvā )= in East; pūrva (prep.)= Eastern
- 6.5. दिशि diśi (m,f. loc. sing. of diśas)= in region
- 6.6. आकाशस्य ākāśasya (m, n. gen. sing. of ākāśa)= of sky , of space, of heaven, of aerospace, of the vacuity
- 6.7. प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् pramāṇamudgrahītum = (see 5.8)
- 6.8. सुभूतिराह-नो subhūtirāha-no =
- subhūtir<= subhūtiḥ [m. nom, sing. of subhūti./ preceding vow. “ā” (of āha), iḥ => ir , (7th VSR) ]= Venerable Subhuti.
- āha(v)= said,replied
- no (adv.)= and not, no (otherwise)
- 6.9.हीदं hīdaṁ (ind. hI)= oh!
- 6.10- भगवन् bhagavan (m, adj. voc. sing. of bhagavat)= Oh! God, Lord, divine or adorable one, name of a Buddha,
-------------------
     (7.1). भगवानाह-एवं bhagavānāha-evaṁ
- bhagavān (m. nom. sing. of bhagavat)= God, Lord, divine or adorable one, name of a Buddha,
- āha (v)= said, / - evaṁ (ind.)= sameness of manner, in such a manner, in this way.
-7.2. दक्षिणपश्चिमोत्तरासु dakṣiṇapaścimottarāsu = in south-west-northern
- dakṣiṇapaścima [adj./ a + u (of ttarāsu) = o (1st PR)] = southwestern.
- uttarāsu (adj. loc. pl. of uttarā)= in Northern
-7.3. अधadha (adj.)= below, under
7.4. ऊर्ध्वं ūrdhvaṁ <= ūrdhvam (ind. m=>ṁ, (by 10th CSR) ]= above, in the upper region
-7.5. दिग्विदिक्षु digvidikṣu ( adj. digvidikstha)= encompassing,
- 7.6. समन्ताद्दशसु samantāddaśasu
- samantād <= samantāt [adv. / preceding soft “d”(of daśasu), hard “t” => d (by 2nd CSR/3)] = round about
-daśasu (num. loc. pl of dazan)= ten,
- 7.7.दिक्षु dikṣu ( )= direction (?)
7.8. सुकरमाकाशस्य sukaramākāśasya =
- sukaram (adj)= easy for (see 5.7)
- ākāśasya (m.n.) = of sky, of space (see 6.6)
- 7.9. प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् pramāṇamudgrahītum = (see 5.8)
- 7.10. सुभूतिराह-नो subhūtirāha-no = (see 6.8 )
-7.11- हीदं भगवन् hīdaṁ bhagavan = (see 6.9 - 6.10)
--------------------
     -(8.1)- भगवानाह-एवमेव bhagavānāha-evameva =
- bhagavānāha = (see 7.1)
- evameva (indecl.)= similarly, in the same manner as above, just so.
- 8.2. सुभूते यो subhūte yo
- subhūte = (see 1.3)
- yo (prn, yaḥ) = who, anyone who
- 8.3. बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito = (see 5.3)
- 8.4. दानं ददाति dānaṁ dadāti= (see 5.4)
- 8.5.तस्य tasya (poss.prn.)= his
- 8.6. सुभूते subhūte (m. voc. )= (see 1.3)
8.7. पुण्यस्कन्धस्य puṇyaskandhasya= the quantity of virtue (of) or merit, (see    5.6) .
8.8. न सुकरं na sukaraṁ =not easy to… (see 5.7)
8.9. प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् pramāṇamudgrahītum= right measure (see 5.8)
---------------
      (9.1). एवं हि सुभूते evaṁ hi subhūte=
- evaṁ (ind. .)=thus, so.
- hi (adv.)= for, just, indeed,
- subhūte =(see 1.3)
- 9.2. बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन bodhisattvayānasaṁprasthitena = set out in the Bodhisattva Vehicle.
- bodhisattva (n)= Bodhisattva, enlightened deing, one who has perfec wisdom and compassion.
- yāna (n)= car, wagon, vehicle
- saṁprasthitena (adj. instr. sing.of samprasthita)= advancing towards buddha hood, set out on journey. departed.
- 9.3. दानं दातव्यं dānaṁ dātavyaṁ=should be giving the gift
- dānaṁ= (see 5.4 )
- dātavyaṁ (adj. acc. sing.of dātavya)= to be placed upon, should be given.
- 9.4. यथा yathā (indecl.)= in such a manner as follows, for instance,
- 9.5. न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि na nimittasaṁjñāyāmapi = even without concepyion about reason
- na(adv)= no, not, without
- nimitta (n)= cause, reason, sign, mark, sake,
- saṁjñāyām <= sañjñāyām [f. loc. sing of sañjñā/ Followed by Palatal “j”, ṁ => ñ (nasal of Palatal class), see 11th CSR ]= in conception, notion, consciousness,
- api (indecl.)= even, also, too.
- 9.5. प्रतितिष्ठेत् pratitiṣṭhet (v)= relied on, depended upon, (see 4.7)
--------------------

     II. Các Bản Dịch P4.
     2/ English ( Ed. Conze)- E4.

       Moreover, Subhuti, a Bodhisattva who gives a gift should not be supported by a thing, nor should he be supported anywhere.

  When he gives gifts he should not be supported by sight objects,

  nor by sounds, smells, tastes, touchables, or mind-objects.

  For, Subhuti, the Bodhisattva, the great being should give gifts in such a way that he is not supported by the notion of a sign.

  And why? Because the heap of merit of that Bodhi-being, who unsupported gives a gift, is not easy to measure.

  - “ What do you think, Subhuti, is the extent of space in the East easy to measure? “
Subhuti replied: “ No indeed, O Lord.”

  The Lord asked: “ In like manner, is it easy to measure the extent of space in the South, West or North, downwards, upwards, in the intermediate directions, in all the ten directions all round? “
- Subhuti replied: “ No indeed, O Lord. “

   The Lord said: “ Even so the heap of merit of that Bodhibeing who unsupported gives a gift is not easy to measure.

 2/ That is why, Subhuti, those who have set out in the Bodhisattva vehicle, should give gifts without being supported by the notion of a sign. “

------------------------

     2/ Tiếng Việt - V4

     1. Lại nữa, Tu Bồ Đề! Bồ tát khi làm việc bố thí không nên dựa vào điều này điều nọ , không nên căn cứ vào chỗ này chô kia.
    2. Tức là, không dựa vào hình sắc mà bố thí.
     3. Không dựa vào âm thanh, mùi , vị, sự xúc chạm, và điều suy nghĩ mà bố thí.
     4. Tu Bồ Đề! Đối với Bồ tát và Đại Bồ tát nên theo cách như vậy mà bố thí, tức là không dựa vào hình tướng .
    5. Tu Bồ Đề, tại sao vây? Bỡi vì một Bồ tát không dựa vào hình tướng để bố thí,Tu Bồ Đề, thì phước đức của Bồ tát ấy không dễ đo lường được.
      6. ” Tu Bồ Đề ! Ông nghĩ thế nào ?Có dễ đo lường hết được không gian phương Đông hay không?”
    Tu Bồ đề đáp: “ Bạch Thế Tôn! Không “
     7. Phật hỏi: “ Tương tự như vậy, có dễ đo lường không gian của Nam, Tây, Bắc phương, bên dưới, bên trên và các phương bao quanh, hết thảy mười phương được hay không?
Tu Bồ Đề đáp: “ Bạch Thế Tôn ! Không.”
Phật bảo: “ Cũng vậy, Tu Bồ Đề! Bồ tát không dựa vào hình thướng mà bố thí , Tu Bồ Đề! Công đức của Bồ tát ấy không dễ đo lường hết được.”
     9. “ Tu Bồ Đề! Những người phát tâm Đại thừa Bồ tát nên theo cách như vậy, không dựa vào hình tướng mà bố thí.

                                                     -//-


                                        KINH KIM CANG

                                       THE DIAMOND SUTRA


                                     (With Sanskrit Vocabulary)

                              P5 : Nguyên Tắc Tri Nhận Thực Tại

                                                 ---------------

                   
वज्रच्छेदिका नाम त्रिशतिका प्रज्ञापारमिता । 

                          || नमो भगवत्या आर्यप्रज्ञापारमितायै॥
                                          -----------------------

         Vajracchedikā nāma triśatikā prajñāpāramitā |

                       || namo bhagavatyā āryaprajñāpāramitāyai ||

                                     ---------------------------
     I . Sanskrit P5.
      1/ Devanagari - S5


    
(1) तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्।
     (2) न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः|
    (3) तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या सा भगवन् लक्षणसंपत्तथागतेन भाषिता सैवालक्षणसंपत्|
    (4) एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत् यावत्सुभूते लक्षणसंपत् तावन्मृषा, यावदलक्षणसंपत् तावन्न मृषेति हि लक्षणालक्षणतस्तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः॥ ५॥

------------------
     2/ Romanized (IAST) and Numbered - S5

     (1.1) tatkiṁ 1.2 manyase subhūte 1.3 lakṣaṇasaṁpadā 1.4 tathāgato 1.5 draṣṭavyaḥ ? 1.6 subhūtirāha-no 1.7 hīdaṁ bhagavan|
     (2.1) na lakṣaṇasaṁpadā 2.2 tathāgato 2.3 draṣṭavyaḥ |
     (3.1) tatkasya hetoḥ ? 3.2 yā sā bhagavan 3.3 lakṣaṇasaṁpattathāgatena 3.4 bhāṣitā 3.5 saivālakṣaṇasaṁpat |
    (4.1) evamukte 4.2 bhagavānāyuṣmantaṁ 4.3 subhūtimetadavocat 4.4 yāvatsubhūte 4.5 lakṣaṇasaṁpat 4.6 tāvanmṛṣā, 4.7 yāvadalakṣaṇasaṁpat 4.8 tāvanna 4.8 mṛṣeti hi 4.9 lakṣaṇālakṣaṇatastathāgato 4.10 draṣṭavyaḥ ||5|
---------------------
      3/ Vocabulary - S5:
     (1.1) तत्किं tatkiṁ = what’s that ?
- tat (pron.)= that / - kim (indecl.)[ m =>ṁ (by 10thCSR)]= what
1.2 मन्यसे सुभूते manyase subhūte = Subhuti! Do you think ?
- manyase<= manyate ( v4. pres. ātm. 2ndpers.sing. ) = you think
- subhūte [m. voc. sing. of subhūti (name of person)] = Subhuti !
-1.3लक्षणसंपदा lakṣaṇasaṁpadā = bythe possessed traits
- lakṣaṇa (n )= mark, symptom, symbol, trait, sign
- saṁpadā (f. instr. sing. of saṁpad) = possession, riches, abundance
1.4  तथागतो tathāgato<= tathāgataḥ (adj. m.nom. sing. of tathāgata / followed by soft cons. “d” (of draṣṭavyaḥ), aḥ => o (by 2ndVSR)] = he who comes and goes in the same way, Gautama Buddha.
1.5 द्रष्टव्यः draṣṭavyaḥ (adj. nom. sing, of draṣṭavya)= to be seen or investigated, visible
1.6 सुभूतिराह-नो subhūtirāha-no = Subhuti replied: No.
- subhūtir<= subhūtiḥ [m. nom, sing. of subhūti./ preceding vow. “ā” (of āha), iḥ => ir , (7th VSR) ]= (person name), Venerable Subhuti.
- āha(v)= said,replied
- no (adv.)= not, no (otherwise).
1.7 हीदं भगवन् hīdaṁ bhagavan = Oh! Lord,
-हीदं hīdaṁ (ind. hI)= oh!
- भगवन् bhagavan (m, voc. sing. of bhagavat)= Oh! God, World’s Lord, World Honored One, name of a Buddha,
---------------------
     (2.1) न लक्षणसंपदा na lakṣaṇasaṁpadā = no possession of the signs    (see        1.3)
2.2 तथागतो tathāgato <= tathāgataḥ (m. nom. sing. of tathāgata)= (see 1.4)
2.3 द्रष्टव्यः draṣṭavyaḥ = to be seen, (see 1.5)
---------------------
     (3.1) तत्कस्य हेतोः tatkasya hetoḥ ? =
that is whose the sake? What’s for reason ?
- tatkasya (sent.)= whose that,
- hetoḥ ? =(m. gen. sing. of heto)= for, for the sake of
3.2 या सा भगवन् yā sā bhagavan
- yā (pron.)= who, which
- sā (pron.)= it, that, this, she
- bhagavan (m)= (see 1.7)
3.3 लक्षणसंपत्तथागतेन lakṣaṇasaṁpattathāgatena =
- lakṣaṇa (n) = mark, sign, trait, (see 1.3)
- saṁpat <= saṁpad [ f. / Cons “d” followed by initial hard cons. “t” (of tathāgatena, so “d” => “t” ( by 5thCSR )]= possession, abundance.
- tathāgatena (m. adj. instr. sing. of tathāgata)= by he who comes and goes in the same way, by Gautama Buddha.
3.4 भाषिता bhāṣitā (n.adj.) = speech, said.
3.5 सैवालक्षणसंपत् saivālakṣaṇasaṁpat = that is truly not possessing the signs.
- saivā = [sa that is) + eva (really) [ a+e = ai ( by 2ndPrR.)]= that is really , truly
- alakṣaṇasaṁpat ( Pref. “a” = not, no)= no possession the signs.
-----------------------
     (4.1) एवमुक्ते evamukte =
- evam (indecl.)= thus, so
- ukte (pp. loc. of ukta)= said, spoken
4.2 भगवानायुष्मन्तं bhagavānāyuṣmantaṁ
- bhagavān (m. nom. sing. of bhagavat)= The Lord, the Buddha.
- āyuṣmantaṁ [adj. acc. sing. of āyuṣmat/ Preceding a cons. “s” (of subhuti), “ m “ (of -antam) => “ ṁ “ (by 10thCSR)]= old, aged
4.3 सुभूतिमेतदवोचत् subhūtimetadavocat=
- subhūtim (m. acc. sing, off subhuti)= aged Subhuti
- etad (pron.)= this, in this manner, so, thus
- avocat= (said ?)
4.4 यावत्सुभूते yāvatsubhūte = subhūti! As long as….
-yāvat <= yāvad [adv. Followed by hard cons. “s” (of subhūte, “d”=> “t” (by 2ndCSR )]= as long as, while
- subhūte (m. voc. sing. of subhūti)= subhūti !
4.5 लक्षणसंपत् lakṣaṇasaṁpat = possession of the signs, (see 3.3).
4.6 तावन्मृषा tāvanmṛṣā= so great in vain, delusion
- tāvan (adj. voc. sing.of tāvat)= so much, so great, up to which
- mṛṣā (adv.)= nonsensically, falsely, in vain, delusion,
4.7 यावदलक्षणसंपत् yāvadalakṣaṇasaṁpat
- yāvad = as long as, (see 4.4)
- alakṣaṇasaṁpat = not possessing the signs (see 3.5)
4.8 तावन्न tāvanna
- tāvan = so much, so great, (see 4.6)
- na (adv.)= not
4.8 मृषेति हि mṛṣeti hi
- mṛṣeti = (see 4.6)
- hi (adv.)= indeed, of course, certainly
4.9 लक्षणालक्षणतस्तथागतो lakṣaṇālakṣaṇatastathāgato =
- lakṣaṇa (n. )= mark, sign, indication, trait, symbol
- alakṣaṇa = [n / a + a = ā (by 2ndPR)]= no sign, no mark,
- tas (tat ?) = that
- tathāgato <= tathāgataḥ [ adj. nom. sing. of tathāgata / Followed by soft “d” ( of draṣṭavyaḥ ), aḥ=> o (by 2ndVSR)]= Thus-gone, One comes and goes in the same way, Gautama Buddha.
4.10 द्रष्टव्यः draṣṭavyaḥ (adj. nom. sing. of draṣṭavya)= to be seen, to be investigated, visible
---------------------
     II. Các Bản Dịch:
     1/ English (Ed. Conze) - V5


      The Lord continued: “ What do you think, Subhuti, can the Tathagata be seen by the possession of his marks?”
Subhuti replied: “ No indeed, O Lord.
 …………..
  And why? What has been taught by the Tathagata as the possession of marks, that is truly a no-possession of no-marks.”
  The Lord said: “ Wherever there is possession of marks, there is fraud, wherever there is no-possession of no-marks there is no fraud. Hence the Tathagata is to be seen from no marks as marks.” |५|
-----------------------

    
2/ Tiếng Việt - V5:

     1. Phật hỏi: “ Tu Bồ Đề! Ông nghĩ sao? Qua thân tướng có thể thấy được Như Lai hay không ?”
- Tu Bồ Đề thưa : ” Bạch Thế Tôn! Không.
     2. “ Không thể dựa vào các tướng mà thấy biết Như Lai.
3. “ Tại sao vậy ? Bạch Thế Tôn! Bỡi vì Như Lai dạy rằng: Những gì gọi là thân tướng tức không phải thực thân tướng.”
     4. Rồi Phật dạy Trưởng lão Tu Bồ Đề: “ Này Tu Bồ Đề! Trong bao lâu còn bám chấp tướng thì bấy nhiêu lâu còn vọng tưởng; khi nào không chấp tướng khi đó không có vọng tưởng. Nếu thấy các tướng đều không phải là tướng tức là thấy dược Như Lai.”

                                                                 )()(

     Phú Yên, THáng Tám, Tân Sửu - 2921

                                 Đàm Khánh Hỷ
 

----------------------

     Tài Liêu Tham Khảo:


      1. Edward Conze (trans.). “ The Diamond Sutra In Sanskrit and English “ <<https://dieungu.org/images/file/eoCd1LFR0ggQAE4R/diamond-sutra-edward-conze.pdf >>
    2/ “ Vajracchedika Prajñaparamita” (University of Oslo, Faculty of Humanities) <<https://www2.hf.uio.no/polyglotta/index.php?page=record&vid=22&level=1&cid=43972>> 

    3. Thích Nhất Hạnh (dg). “ KINH KIM CƯƠNG
GƯƠM BÁU CẮT ĐỨT PHIỀN NÃO” <<https://thuvienhoasen.org/p16a16012/3/kinh-kim-cuong-guom-bau-cat-dut-phien-nao>>
     4/ TKh. Thích Duy Lực (dg). “KINH KIM CANG BÁT NHÃ BA LA MẬT” ( Từ Ân Thiền Đường, USA.)<<hoavouu.com/a23288/kinh-kim-cang-bat-nha-ba-la-mat>>
     5/ Christian, Richard (trad.). “ La Prajñaparamita.-
Le Sûtra du Diamant.” <<http://www.centrebouddhisteparis.org/Sangharakshita/Le_soutra_du_Diamant/le_soutra_du_diamant.htm>>
     6/ Thich Nhat Hanh (dg) .”LE SUTRA DU DIAMANT”
(Albin Michel, 1997)<<http://mpcmontreal.org/?q= fr/node/551>>
    7/ Ursula, Richard (Über.). “Prajnaparamita Sutra”
(Buddha Diamant-Sutra) <<https://www.buddhismus-deutschland.de/wpcontent/uploads/material_diamantsutra.pdf>>
     8/ DSBC Staff (input). || वज्रच्छेदिका नाम त्रिशतिका प्रज्ञापारमिता ||
(University of the West - Nagarjuna Institute of Exact Methods, 2004) << http://www.dsbcproject.org/canon-text/content/403/1863>>
    9/ Huệ Hải (input). “Kinh Kim Cang (Phạn Ngữ” (Trường Trung Cấp Phật Học Khánh Hòa ) <<http://www.kbc.edu.vn/vi/blog/kinh-kim-cang--phan-ngu-.39>>
    10/ Wikipedia - Tiếng Việt “ Kim Cương Kinh “
<<https://vi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_c%C6%B0%C6%A>>
    11/ Đoàn Trun Còn – Nguyễn Minh Tiến (dg). “Kinh Kim Cang Bát Nhã Ba La Mật” (Phật Pháp Ứng Dụng)<<ttps://phatphapungdung.com/phap-bao/kinh-kim-cang-bat-nha-ba-la-mat-64388.html>>
 

                                                                                 -//-

 

Thứ Hai, 19 tháng 7, 2021

Kỳ 6: Ba Mươi Bài Tụng Duy Biểu Thức

 

                       Kỳ 5: Bài  26 -  30

                       -----------

                       त्रिंशिका             

            विज्ञप्तिमात्रता -   कारिका                    

                               
               Tri
ṃśikā - vijñaptimātratā - kārikā
                             Vasubandhu
                                   ---------
                                     Bài  26
    I. Sanskrit:
    1/ Devanagari:

 

     26.  यावद्विज्ञप्तिमात्रत्वे विज्ञानं नावतिष्ठते ।
    
ग्राहद्वयस्यानुशयस्तावन्न विनिवर्तते
॥  
  

    2/ Romanized (IAST):
    26. yāvadvijñaptimātratve vijñānaṁ nāvatiṣṭhati ।
grāhadvayasyānuśayastāvanna vinivartate ॥   

    3/ Vocabulary - 26:
    (1)- यावद्  yāvad (adv.)= as long as, while.

    (2)- विज्ञप्तिः  vijñaptiḥ (f) = representation, report, information, notification.

  (3)-  मात्रत्वे mātratve ( mātratva) [ n. loc. sing. of mātratva, suffixe “-tva”  = “-ness”  = at one thing and no more, in oneness, on the   wholeness .

  (4)- विज्ञानं vijñānaṁ (n. acc. sing. of vijñāna )= consciousness, understanding, wisdom, knowledge, recognition, intelligence .

  (5)- न​ na (adv.)= not, no.

      - अवतिष्ठति avatiṣṭhati (veb)= abide, situated, stand up.

  (6)-  ग्राह​ grāha m,adj)= seizing, taking, receiving.

  (7)-द्वयस्य​  dvayasya (n,adj. gen. sing. of   dvayasya    )= of two things, of the pair, of the couple, twofold.

  (8)- अनुशयः  anuśayaḥ => anuśayas (m. nom. sing. of anuśaya  / “aḥ”  followed by Dental “t” (of tāvan), so ḥ => “s” (see 3rd VSR)]= close  attachment to any object.

   (9)- तावन् tāvan [tāvad (adv.) / cons. “d” (of tāvad) followed by Nasal “n” (of na), so “d” => “n” its Nasal in Dental class (see 6th CSR)]= During that time, meanwhile.

   (10)- न na (adv.)= not, not yet, no

  (11)-विनिवर्तते vinivartate (v. vinivṛt )= disappear, cease, end, be extinguished .

    II. Các Bản Dịch

    1/ English:

    26. As long as the consciousness has not abode in the   real  nature of unique consciousness only, the   attachment to  the  ego - dharmas  twofold differentiation during that time   can  not be   extinguished.   

    

 2/ 漢 文(法師玄奘譯)

  26. 乃至未起識   

求住唯識性   

於二取隨眠   

猶未能伏滅

 

     3/ Âm Hán - Việt:

 Nãi chí vị khởi thức

Cầu trú Duy thức tánh

Ư nhị thủ Tùy miên

Dụ vị năng phục diệt

 

    4/ Tiếng Việt:

    26. Trong bao lâu tâm thức chưa trụ vào thực tánh Duy thức, thì sự bám chấp vào phân biệt ngã-pháp trong thời gian đó không thể bị trừ  bỏ.

---------------------------
                                  Bài 27:

    I. Sanskrit:
    1/ Devanagari:

 27.  विज्ञप्तिमात्रमेवेदमित्यपि ह्युपलम्भतः ।
स्थापयन्नग्रतः किंचित्‌ तन्मात्रे नावतिष्ठते ॥
  
 

    2/ Romanized (IAST):
  27- Vijñaptimātramevedamityapi hyupalambhataḥ ।
sthāpayannagrataḥ kiṁcit tanmātre nāvatiṣṭhate ॥  
   

    3/ Vocabulary - 27:

  (1)- विज्ञप्तिः  vijñaptiḥ (f) = representation, report, information, notification.
  (2)- मात्र​ mātra (n)= only, only one, one thing and no more.

   (3)- मे me (indcl)= for me, to me.

  (4)- vedam (m. acc. sing. of veda)= true knowledge, property, perception, obtaining

  (5)-   इति  iti => ity ([ind./ final “i” (of iti) preceding “a” (of api), so “i”=> “y” (4th PrR)] = so, thus , that is,

  (6)- अपि api (indcl.)= also, too, even.

   (7)- हि hi => hy [indcl. /preceding  “u” , “i” => “y”  (4th PrR) ] = indeed,   surely, because, for.

  (8)- उपलम्भ upalambha  (m)= detection, recognition, perception, obtainment.
 (9)- sthāpayati (verb)= set up, establish, institute,

  (10)- अग्रतः agrataḥ (indcl)= forward, in front, before, at first.

  (11)- किञ्चित्   kiñcit =>kiṁcit  [ ind.)= something, a little, little bit
 (12)-तन्मात्रे  tanmātre (n. loc. sing.of tanmātra)= at the subtle element, mere essence, merely that .

    (13)- नna (adv)= not, no
  (14)-  अवतिष्ठते  avatiṣṭhate ( verb )= abide in a state, remain standing, be absorbed in .

 

II. Các Bản Dịch

    1/ English:

    27.  Someone  set up   in front   even a little thing  of which he   thinks   that  is also  the  nature of the  unique consciousness     being really  obtained by him . For  merely that,  he does not abide in the   unique consciousness  .     

       

   2/ 漢 文(法師玄奘譯)

   27. 現前立少物   

謂是唯識性   

以有所得故   

非實住唯識.

 

     3/ Âm Hán-Việt:

 Hiện tiền lập thiểu vật

Vị thị Duy thức tánh

Dĩ hữu sở đắc cố

Phi thật trú Duy thức

 

    4/ Tiếng Việt:

    27. Có người còn  nêu ra trước mắt  một thứ gì  dẫu  là nhỏ bé  mà  cho rằng đó cũng chính là Duy thức tánh mà mình đạt được. Chỉ vì còn bám chấp sở đắc như vậy mà người ấy  chưa thực sự an trụ Duy thức tánh.   

 -----------------------
                                       Bài 28:
    I. Sanskrit:
    1/ Devanagari:

    28. यदालम्बनं  विज्ञानं नैवोपलभते  तदा ।
स्थितं विज्ञानमात्रत्वे ग्राह्याभावे तदग्रहात् ॥
 
     

   2/ Romanized (IAST):
     28 - Yadā   ālambanaṁ jñānaṁ naivopalabhate tadā । sthitaṁ vijñānamātratve

grāhyābhāve tadagrahāt ॥ 28 ॥
    3/ Vocabulary - 28:
  (1)- यद​yada, yadā (cj)= when, whenever.

  (2)- आलम्बनं ālambanaṁ [ n. acc. sing. of ālambana / followed by a cons. ‘j’ , m => ṁ (10th CSR)/ (a, ā)+ (a, ā)=ā (3rd PrR) ] = contributory cause, base, support, (object of consciousness) .

   (3)- विज्ञानं vijñānaṁ (n. acc. sing. of vijñāna )= wisdom, intelligence, consciousness,  cognition.

  (4)- न​ na (adv.)= not,  no.

  (5)- एवeva   (indcl.) [vṛddhi  ai = a + e ; guṇa  o = a + u (2nd PrR)]= really, thus 
     (6)- उपलभते upalabhate (v. upa-labh)= obtain, get possession of,  seize, receive .
 
(7)- तदा tadā (ind.)= then, at that time.
 
(8)- स्थितं sthitaṁ (n.adj. acc.sing. of sthita )= standing firm, situated in, abiding in .

  (9)-विज्ञान  vijña  (n) = wisdom, intelligence, comprehending,   cognition

  - मात्रत्वे  mātratve ( mātratva) [ n. loc. sing. of mātratva, suffixe “-tva”  = “-ness”  = at one thing and no more, in oneness, in the   wholeness .

  - विज्ञानमात्रत्वे vijñānamātratve (n. locc. sing. of vijñānamātratva)= in the nature of unique consciousness.

 

 (10)- ग्राह्य  grāhya (adj)= to be held, to be seized, to be recognized.

  - अभावे abhāve (m. loc. sing. of abhāva)= in nullity, in non-existence, in negation, in destruction, in the  annihilation.

(11)-  तत् tat =>  तद्  tad (pron. / final  harf cons. “t” followed by a vowel “a” (of agrahāt, so  t => d (2nd CSR/3 )= that

 -  अग्रहात् agrahāt (m. abl. sing. of agraha)= non acceptance, no taking, non  seizer,
   II. Các Bản Dịch

    1/ English:

    28. Whenever  the  cultivator   does really not  obtain   any  the  objective  and subjective    cognitions, he , at that time, has  abode in the nature of unique consciousness, because  in   annihilating  the  object   grasped    that is no more the subject grasping.    

 

      2/ 漢 文(法師玄奘譯)

  28. 若時於所緣   

智都無所得 

 爾時住唯識   

離二取相故.

    3/ Âm Hán - Việt:

 Nhược thời ư sở duyên

Trí đô vô sở đắc

Nhĩ thời trú Duy thức

Ly nhị thủ tướng cố

    4/ Tiếng Việt:

    28.Khi một người  thực sự không có  thủ đắc được gì  về sở tri và   năng   tri , ngay lúc đó người ấy đã an trú trong tánh duy thức, vì trong sự tiêu trừ đối tượng sở  thủ thì chủ thể năng thủ cũng không còn nữa.  

------------
                                     Bài 29:
    I. Sanskrit:
    1/ Devanagari:

   29. अचित्तोऽनुपलम्भोऽसौ ज्ञानं  लोकोत्तरं च तत् ।
     
आश्रयस्य परावृत्तिर्द्विधा दौष्ठुल्यहानितः ॥
 
2/ Romanized (IAST):
    29. Acitto'nupalambho'sau jñānaṁ lokottaraṁ ca tat ।
āśrayasya parāvṛttirdvidhā   dauṣṭhulyahānitaḥ ॥  

    3/ Vocabulary - 29:
   (1)- अचित्तः acittaḥ (adj./ followed by “a” ,  aḥ => “o” and “a” => ‘ (2nd VSR)  ] = inconceivable, not an object of thought
(2)- अनुपलम्भः  anupalambhaḥ =>anupalambho  (m. nom. sing. of anupalambha)  = non-perception, non- obtainment.
  (3)- असौ asau => ‘sau [m./ preced by -aḥ, “a” => ‘ (2nd VSR )] = that
  (4)- ज्ञानं jñānaṁ (n. acc. sing. of vijñāna )= wisdom, intelligence, consciousness,  cognition.

 (5)-  लोकोत्तरं lokottaraṁ (n. adj. acc. sing. of lokottara )= supermundane, surpassing the world.
(6)- च ca (cj)= and .
(7)-तत्  tat (prn.)= that.

 (8)- आश्रयस्य āśrayasya (m. gen. sing. of  āśraya) = of  the base, source, support, platform, recipient  .
   (9)- परावृत्तिः parāvṛttiḥ => parāvṛttir [f. nom. sing. of  parāvṛtti./ followed by a soft cons. “d” ( of  dvidhā ),  ḥ (of -iḥ) => r  (see 7th VSR)] = exchange, interchange, restoration of  property,  revolving.

  (10)- द्विधा dvidhā (ind.)= two kinds, twofold, dual .
  -  हानि hāni (f, adj)= loss, giving up, taking off, abandoned,

- दौष्ठुल्य dauṣṭhulya (n)= evil tendency, error,  wickedness, badness.

II. Các Bản Dịch

    1/ English:

    29.That  non-obtainment is   inconceivable, it  is the wisdom surpassing the world. And   that is   interchange of the base of all consciousnesses  for the realisation of   two results (Nirvana and Sambodhi),  through    two the   obstacle tendencies (affliction and knowledge)   being  abandoned. 

 

   2/ 漢 文(法師玄奘譯)

   29. 無得不思議   

是出世間智   

捨二粗重故   

便證得轉依

 

   3/ Âm Hán - Việt:

 Vô đắc bất tư nghì

Thị Xuất thế gian trí

Xả nhị thô trọng cố

Tiện chứng đắc Chuyển y

 

    4/ Tiếng Việt:

   29. Vô sở đắc ấy  không thể nghĩ bàn,    vượt qua  trí thế gian. Và,  đó  là sự   chuyển   sở  y     các thức  mà  chứng hai quả   ( Niết bàn và Đại bồ  đề)   qua việc xả bỏ  hai thứ chướng  ngại ,  phiền não và sở  tri chướng.    

-----------------------------

                                       Bài 30:
    I. Sanskrit:
    1/ Devanagari:

    30.  स एवानास्रवो  धातुरचिन्त्यः कुशलो ध्रुवः ।
सुखो विमुक्तिकायोऽसौ धर्माख्योऽयं महामुनेः॥    ॥

2/ Romanized (IAST):
    30. सSa evānāsravo dhāturacintyaḥ kuśalo dhruvaḥ ।
sukho vimuktikāyo'sau dharmākhyo'yaṁ mahāmuneḥ ॥  

   

    3/ Vocabulary - 30:
 (1)- स sa (m. nom. sing. prn.)= it ( the  realisation said  in 29th  verse).

  (2) - एव​  eva (indcl.)= really
  (3)- अनास्रवः  anāsravaḥ => nāsravo [adj. / a + a =  ā (3rd PrR)/ Preceding a soft cons. “d”, aḥ => o ((2nd VSR/2)]  =  pure, without leakage, free from mundane inclinations.

  (3)- धातुः dhātuḥ => dhātur (m. nom. sing. of dhātu./ preceded by “u” and followed by a vow. “a”, ḥ => r  (7th VSR)  ]= constituent, component, essential ingredient of body, region, realm,
(4)-    acintyaḥ (adj. )= incomprehensible, unthinkable, beyond thought.
  (5)- कुशलः kuśalaḥ => kuśalo [n, adj. /aḥ => o , see (3) above ]=auspicious, good, happy, virtue, welfare.
(6)- ध्रुवः dhruvaḥ (adj.)= fixed, firm, immovable, permanent, constant, eternal.
(7)- सुखः sukhaḥ => sukho(n. adj. nom. sing. of sukha/ preceding a soft  letter “v” , aḥ => o (see 2nd VSR/2)]= delightful, pleasant, joy, happiness
(8)- विमुक्ति vimukti (f. )= liberation, emancipation, release, deliverance.

  - कायः kāyaḥ (m. nom. sing. of kāya)= body, assemblance, house.

 -विमुक्तिकायः vimuktikāyaḥ => vimuktikāyo (m.nom.sing./ preceding “a” (of asau), aḥ => o and  “a” => ‘ (see 2nd VSR) ]= the emancipated body, body of liberation, one of the five attributes of dharmakaya.
  (9) - असौ asau => ‘sau (m. nom. sing. prn.)= that (over there).
(10)- धर्म​ dharma (m)= doctrine, law, method, phenomena, thing, truth,

  - आख्या  ākhyā (v)= name, call, appell

  (11)- अयम् ayam (idam)=>ayaṁ [m.nom. sing. / followed by a cons. m => ṁ (10th CSR )]= this .

  (12)- महा mahā (prefix) = great, large,

  -  मुनेः  muneḥ (m. gen. sing. of muni)= of the sage, saint, holy man

-  महामुनेः mahāmuneḥ (m. gen.)= of the great sage.

  
II. Các Bản Dịch

    1/ English:

    30. It is really  the realm free from  mundane inclinations, unthinkable, auspicious , permanent, and joyful . That is the emancipated  body , this Dharma   is named  that  of  great sage.

 

    2/ 漢 文(法師玄奘譯)

 此即無漏界,   

不思議,善,常 ,  

安樂,解脫 身,   

大牟尼 名法.

 

   3/ Âm Hán - Việt:

 Thử tức Vô lậu giới,

Bất tư nghì ,Thiện, Thường,

An lạc, Giải thoát thân.

Đại Mâu Ni danh pháp

 

    4/ Tiếng  Việt:

    30. Đó là cảnh giới  bất  nhiễm thế tục, không thể nghĩ bàn, thiện hảo, thường hằng, an lạc, đó là   thân giải thoát,     Pháp đó   là Pháp thấn thanh tịnh đại trí huệ.

 

                    ( Hết Ba Mươi Bài Tụng Duy Biểu Thức)

 

  Phú Yên Tháng Sáu, Tân Sửu - 2021

                                       Đàm Khánh Hỷ,

 

-------------------------

    Tài Liêu Tham Khảo:

    1. Thich Thuyền Ấn (dg.). Duy Thức Tam Thập Tụng (Vasubandhu author). ( Chủa Bửu Minh: Ban BT. Tài Liêu Cao Học Triết, 1972-1973),<<http://www.chuabuuminh.vn/PrintView.aspx?Language=vi&ID=77D059>>
     2. Dharmapāla et al. [
法師玄奘 & Thích Thiện Siêu (dg)], Vijñaptimātratāsiddhi Sastra (Thành Duy Thức Luận), Thiền Phật Giáo:<< https://thienphatgiao.wordpress.com/2013/11/22/thanh-duy-thuc-luan-thich-thien-sieu-dich/2/>>
      3.Mywhatever.com/sanskrit.Tri
ṃśikā.<<http://www.mywhatever.com /sanskrit/trimsika/verse01.html >>
     4. Thich Thiên Hoa, Duy Thức Học . (Đạo Phật Ngày Nay) << http://www.buddhismtoday.com/viet/phatphap/duythuc_hoc.htm>>
      5. Thích Trí Châu, Duy Thức Tam Thập Tụng Lược Giải. ( Thiền Thất Thanh Lương: Santa Ana CA.USA, 2003) (ebook by Nam Thiên):<<https://www.niemphat.vn/downloads/duy-thuc-tong/hoc-duy-thuc/duy-thuc-tam-thap-tung-luoc-giai-tk-thich-tri-chau.pdf>>
     6. Thích NuwxThanh Trì, Duy Thức Tam Thập Tụng Đối Chiếu Phiên Dịch, (Pháp Luân, thang 7, 2020).<<http://phapluan.vn/index.php/phat-hoc/72-tieng-phan/1521-duy-thuc-tam-thap-tung-doi-chieu-phien-dich>>
   7. Thích Kiên Tuệ, Khái Quat Về Duy Thức Học. Vietheravada: <<https://www.vietheravada.net/bienkhao/duythuchoc.html>>.

                                              -//-